bittah.com!~ No Man's Sky - Page 8
Tribes 1, Tribes 2 and Midair gaming hub for the Australia and New Zealand communities.
We don't mention vengeance or ascend.
Moderator: Super Moderators
- Recent Topics
- Tribes Ascend Modding
- Bittah all time greatest moments
- November 2018 - Tribes 20yr Anniversary
- Midair (formerly known as Project Z)
- What are you watching? TV Megathread (now with added sticky)
I never actually realised just how many people were playing NMS. The hype must have been insane.
Edit: Oh, wait, of course it's not counting consoles for DOom. duh
That big things mod looks great, but i wonder if it's just changing the problem so that all planets now look like that rather than the current design. It'd be good if there was a mixture.
The puzzling part to me is how there are games out there where you basically walk in a straight line for a couple of hours and that is absolutely all you can do and they get near universally praised as something really special. Then you have a game that does much more than that but is criticised for being boring and not doing enough. There is no consistency.Yep. This game is boring.
Not even an inch of depth.
As for No Man's Sky now that I'm at the 'end game' I've been treating it as nothing more than a walking simulator itself and personally it has been really awe-inspiring. While the outposts and locations and their inhabitants, the resources you collect, the other ships you see and the overall gameplay loop are repetitive, I have found that just landing on a planet and setting off on foot can really create some beautiful and unique experiences, even moreso than what those other games do.
I am still being amazed at just what you can find out there if you go looking for it. There are some really beautiful sights, you just won't see them on every planet.
I'd like some names of those 'near universally praised' straight line games.The puzzling part to me is how there are games out there where you basically walk in a straight line for a couple of hours and that is absolutely all you can do and they get near universally praised as something really special.Yep. This game is boring.
Not even an inch of depth.
Discoveries are fucking meaningless anyway and an absolute chore as they have to be individually uploaded.
You land on a planet then:
1. Zoom into a plant or animal and wait about 3 seconds while the scanner locks onto it and 'discovers' it.
2. Press esc and find the thing you discovered in a list
3. Press X to name it - then upload it (or it might be name and upload in the same function).
If you bother to do this you have pages and pages of these animals and plants that look only slightly different requiring an upload on each, you cant mass upload for the planet for example.
The thing that shits me most about this process, not the particularly annoying scanning - that 3 seconds doesnt sound like much, but when it has a zoom attached and you have to do it over and over and over - it gets very fucking old. You also cant scan birds, you have to shoot them out of the sky and scan the corpse. But the thing that shits me - each time you go to a new planet it's 100% reset. Every amazing discovery is linked to each planet - absolute balls. True discovery would have a universal database galaxy wide - where you may encounter animals that other players have found. For example - if you name a Kangaroo in Australia a Kangaroo but find another Kangaroo in America and name it a Womprat - woo discovery!
The only discovery is the random assortment of stuff on each planet, all of which according to the game are 100% unique. It rankles to see plants and animals that are clearly from other planets that are now new. You're discovering this amazing plant (that's just a square with a dent out of it), or a spiral shell looking thing or what not. It's a fucking farce.
I agree with Dreamstation that there are some amazing planets to be found, that's actually true - the random design of them is really quite impressive - but that's also nullified by the repetition in that:
1. The unique thing is planet wide - ie if you have this awesome crater filled planet with water filling the craters, that's the defining feature. Yes it looks great, but if you fly across the planet, that's what you'll find randomly all over place. Underwater looks amazing incidentally, but is always empty. Other than random sea creatures that basically do nothing and are few and far between (there's no really heavily populated fish environments etc).
2. The planets have a single biome. There are no desert and jungle variations, no polar caps or regions - if a planet has snow, the entire planet is snowy. Some have awesome looking storms (that miracuously disappear when you step into your ship or into a cave and look out...then reappear when you exit again)
I've tried hoofing it across planets and it's just dull. Other than your life support systems requiring constant replenishment, there's just fuckall too do. I actually quite like destroying things for resources, there's something quite relaxing about it (not the big rare mineral columns - and pff as if there's anything rare about them). But jesus - there's nothing to do or see once you realise it's all the same.
Stanley Parable and Journey are first to come to mind. Both are great games in their own right but if we're judging a game based purely on the depth of it's gameplay and mechanics, both should be rated much lower than they are.I'd like some names of those 'near universally praised' straight line games.
Granted but if we're talking about value for dollar then I've probably gotten more value from NMS at it's current price than either of those games at their pricing. I absolutely love Journey but each playthrough is exactly the same and after a couple of playthroughs there's nothing at all left to discover or achieve. 10-12 hours if you really stretch it out whereas I've played NMS for 5-6x that amount already and I'm still seeing new things.Slight cost difference between those games and NMS DS.
Not sure I agree with that but value is subjective so neither of us are wrong.NMS should be $20 max but it's premium AAA priced
There was no denying there WAS entertainment in this, but it's like many games - mostly concentrated around the learning the game phase. Once you learn the basics and progress into the game proper, that's where shit just falls apart in this.